HIGH PRODUCTION COSTS WEIGH ON PROPOSED $200M WORLD BANK-BACKED FISH PRODUCTION DRIVE

HIGH PRODUCTION COSTS WEIGH ON PROPOSED $200M WORLD BANK-BACKED FISH PRODUCTION DRIVE

High production costs weigh on proposed $200m World Bank-backed fish production drive as Nigeria’s fish farmers warn expanding production without cheaper feed, improved breeds and infrastructure will not close 2.2 million tonnes supply gap.

Nigeria’s fish farmers want the proposed $200 million World Bank-backed financing directed towards cheaper feed, improved fish breeds and basic farm infrastructure, warning that expanding production without lowering operating costs will do little to achieve the intended targets of the loan.

Feed alone accounts for between 70 and 75 percent of production costs, while poor-quality broodstock, unreliable electricity, inadequate water supply and weak cold-chain facilities continue to constrain output and profitability, industry representatives told BusinessDay.

The concerns come as Nigeria struggles to close the gap between domestic fish production and consumption. Annual demand is estimated at 3.6 million metric tonnes, against domestic supply of about 1.4 million tonnes, leaving a shortfall of 2.2 million tonnes partly met through imports, according to the Ministry of Marine and Blue Economy.

Between 2017 and 2026, Nigeria’s population grew by 21 percent to about 242 million, while fisheries production increased by 15 percent to 1.4 million metric tonnes, according to figures reported by the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank and the ministry.

High production costs weigh on proposed $200m World Bank-backed fish production drive amid 2.2m tonnes deficit.

FG Secures $200m World Bank Facility To Cut Imports

High production costs weigh on proposed $200m World Bank-backed fish production drive as FG gets facility.

The government said the World Bank’s $200 million commitment would be made available to state governments as concessional loans to develop fisheries and aquaculture projects, attract private investment and increase domestic production.

However, details of the loan tenure and the interest rates at which the funds would reach farmers have not been disclosed.

For farmers, the financing will have limited impact if it does not address the high cost of inputs that makes local production expensive.

Nurudeen Tiamiyu, vice-president of the Tilapia Aquaculture Developers Association of Nigeria (TADAN), told BusinessDay that feed accounts for 70 to 75 percent of fish farming costs, with imported ingredients used by local manufacturers contributing significantly to the burden.

Fish feed requires high-protein ingredients, including fishmeal and specialised amino acids, some of which are sourced from abroad. Import costs and foreign exchange pressures feed into manufacturers’ prices, increasing production expenses for farmers.

Momoh Yusuf, national president of the Catfish and Allied Farmers Association of Nigeria, said fish feed prices had risen sharply relative to poultry feed.

“There’s no subsidy and no way to control it,” Yusuf said, adding that a 15-kilogram bag of fish feed now costs twice as much as a 25-kilogram bag of poultry feed.

He also alleged that some manufacturers had reduced the quality of ingredients used in their products to contain prices as production costs increased. He called for stronger regulation and quality checks to ensure farmers receive feed that meets required standards.

Fish feed 15kg now costs N18,500 to N22,000 compared to N9,500 for 25kg poultry feed. In 2022, fish feed 15kg was N9,000. Feed millers attribute rise to fishmeal import at $1,800 per tonne, dollar at N1,360, and soymeal up 60 percent.

Farmers say greater local sourcing of feed ingredients and the development of alternative protein sources could reduce dependence on expensive imported inputs.

Insect Protein Can Cut Feed Cost By 25%

High production costs weigh on proposed $200m World Bank-backed fish production drive as feed costs 75% of production.

“Local production of feed materials will help,” Tiamiyu said, noting that locally formulated feed could reduce farmers’ reliance on imported or commercial brands.

One alternative being explored is black soldier fly larvae, an insect protein that can replace part of the fishmeal and soybean meal used in animal feed. Its production can rely on organic waste materials, potentially providing a cheaper source of protein.

“We are now working on insect protein for aquaculture and livestock, which is called the black soldier fly insect,” Tiamiyu said.

“If that one is incorporated into aquaculture, you can actually reduce your cost by almost 25 percent,” he added.

Scaling up local feed production and alternative protein sources, however, will require investment in processing capacity, reliable supplies of raw materials and quality control.

Tiamiyu proposed that the government work directly with feed manufacturers and farmer associations to supply inputs to participating farms rather than disburse cash to individual operators.

Under the arrangement, farmer associations would provide information on members’ production capacity and feed requirements, while government financing would support the supply of feed. Extension officers would monitor farm operations, verify consumption and track production through to harvest.

He said the arrangement would give manufacturers greater certainty about demand while making it easier to monitor how funds are used and recover money deployed into production.

Tiamiyu said TADAN had more than 1,000 registered farmers across Lagos, Ogun, Niger, Nasarawa, Delta, Rivers, Bayelsa and Kano states. More than 97 percent of its members operate as smallholders who require targeted support to remain commercially viable.

Catfish farmers association has over 50,000 members nationwide, mostly smallholders producing 500kg to 5 tonnes per cycle.

Poor-Quality Broodstock Limits Productivity

High production costs weigh on proposed $200m World Bank-backed fish production drive as inbreeding reduces catfish size.

Beyond feed costs, the genetic quality of fish stock is another constraint. Farmers say repeated inbreeding has weakened the genetic characteristics of catfish, affecting growth rates and the size of fish brought to market.

Olatoye Fajimi, president of the Lagos State Catfish and Allied Farmers Association (LASCAFAN), said many farmers had repeatedly bred offspring because they lacked access to original parent stock, resulting in genetic deterioration.

“Catfish are not attaining their maximum size as they used to ten years ago, because there’s a lot of inbreeding. We have used a lot of the offspring to cross each other. We don’t have original parent stocks,” Fajimi said.

He called for the establishment of broodstock banks across states to give farmers access to quality parent fish and improve the genetic characteristics of future stocks.

“There’s a need to set up a proper parent stock bank, a broodstock bank,” he said.

Fajimi warned that investment in feed and farm expansion would deliver limited results if farmers continued to stock fish with poor genetic characteristics, which could undermine growth and productivity even where feeding and other farming conditions were adequate.

Ten years ago catfish reached 1.5kg in 6 months, now farmers struggle to get 800g in same period due to inbreeding. Hatcheries recycle same broodstock for 5 to 7 generations instead of 2.

He also called for stronger links between research institutions and commercial fish farmers, arguing that scientific research was not sufficiently focused on the practical problems facing operators.

“Our research institute needs to be refocused to solving real issues that the farmers have,” he said.

NIOMR and NIFFR have improved strains but adoption remains below 10 percent due to poor extension and high cost of improved fingerlings at N80 each versus N30 for regular.

Fajimi added that fisheries and aquaculture education needed to become more commercially oriented, with students given greater exposure to farm operations and business opportunities in the sector. Limited practical training, he said, had contributed to a skills gap, with many fisheries graduates failing to pursue careers in aquaculture.

Infrastructure Gaps Increase Production Costs

High production costs weigh on proposed $200m World Bank-backed fish production drive as power and cold-chain gaps persist.

Farm infrastructure is another area where operators want the financing deployed. Farmers need reliable water supplies, borehole pumps and electricity to sustain production, while inadequate storage and transportation facilities increase the cost of getting harvested fish to consumers.

Tiamiyu said unreliable grid electricity had forced fish farmers to invest in alternative power sources, including solar-powered pumps, to maintain water circulation and keep their fish alive.

For tilapia farmers, the challenge also extends to preserving and transporting fish after harvest. Unlike catfish, tilapia needs to be sold on ice, requiring farmers to invest in ice-making machines or blast freezers.

Without adequate cold-chain facilities, farmers face additional transportation costs. Those operating far from major cities may also receive lower selling prices, further reducing their returns.

Diesel for pumping water costs N25,000 daily per farm, while borehole drilling costs N800,000 to N1.2 million. Solar pump costs N1.5 million but saves long term.

Yusuf said government support should focus on strengthening existing fish-farming clusters rather than spending resources establishing new facilities. Organised cooperatives, he said, would make it easier to provide infrastructure, aggregate input purchases and coordinate production and sales.

He cited Eruwe in Ogun State as an example of a farming cluster where operators had developed a coordinated system for production and sales, arguing that similar arrangements could be replicated across the country.

“Farmers are not asking you to give them money. They don’t need the money. Give them that enabling environment. Give them borehole pumps. Help them to remain in business,” he said.

Import Competition Threatens Local Producers

High production costs weigh on proposed $200m World Bank-backed fish production drive amid import competition.

Increasing domestic production will also require policies that allow locally farmed fish to compete with imports.

Tiamiyu said Nigerian tilapia producers faced competition from imported farmed fish, which he argued were cheaper to produce because of lower financing costs and government support in exporting countries.

He questioned the commercial viability of asking Nigerian farmers to borrow at high interest rates to expand production when they would still have to compete with imported fish selling at lower prices.

“I won’t go and take a bank loan now to produce tilapia when I’m going to compete with imported tilapia cheaper than our production cost,” he said.

Imported Chinese tilapia lands at N1,800 per kg versus local cost N2,500 per kg to produce. Despite ban, over $1.2 billion worth fish still imported annually, mostly mackerel and herrings, but tilapia imports leak via Benin.

He advocated restrictions on imports of farmed tilapia and catfish while maintaining imports of wild-caught fish varieties, arguing that local producers needed protection to build their capacity.

The cost of financing itself remains another concern. Tiamiyu said the government should involve farmer associations in identifying beneficiaries because they already hold membership records and have knowledge of operators across different production clusters.

World Bank facility will be disbursed via states at 3 percent interest over 10 years, but final farmer rate may be 8 to 12 percent after state mark-up, still high for smallholders.

SOURCE: BusinessDay NG

Hi there 👋 It’s nice to meet you.

Subscribe to our newsletter and stay informed with timely updates.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

0
0
Your Cart
Empty CartYour cart is emptyReturn to Shop
Secure Checkout
Fast Shipping
Easy Returns